Sunday, January 9, 2011

Week 2 - Pumpkin Pie

Well - Two weeks down.  Fifty to go...
Just to clarify - I made the cheesecake on Wednesday but created the blog yesterday.  So I don't want ANYONE to think I made a cheesecake on Saturday and a pumpkin pie on Sunday.  That was not the case!

So...this weekend was quite the baking adventure! I have made pumpkin pie before but with pillsbury crust and the Libby's recipe on the back of the pumpkin puree...I stepped it up a bit with this recipe.

I planned to make Pumpkin Pie with Ginger crust.  A crust from scratch. I have never done that before and I now know why people buy crust.  Making your own is tough. I once heard that it took someone 20 years to perfect their pie crust. I figured I had better get started......

So the recipe. My stepdad, Tom gave me a cookbook a couple of holidays ago called the Pie and Pastry Bible by Rose Levy Beranbaum and it is dense.  Rose, impressively gives step by step directions on EVERYTHING.  She is a wealth of baking knowledge and she writes very well.  I have to remember to read her words carefully so as not to miss any of the important advice.....So her Basic Flaky Pie Crust was tough. I had to freeze and refrigerate various ingredients for the crust prior to making it so everything was cold when it went into the food processor.  Then I put it all together in my NEW Cuisinart, a Christmas present from my stepmother, Lanie who is a walking advertisement for the brand.  Everyone should have one! I agree Lanie....- thank you again!


The dough had to refrigerate for at least an hour or overnight. Well, I talked myself out of making the entire pie yesterday and chose overnight! Today, I picked back up with rolling.  I made so many mistakes in Rose's detailed directions that it isn't even worth it to list them all! But I didn't have to start over!

The recipe had an interesting twist that I loved.  I food processed four gingersnap cookies (didn't know what those were prior to yesterday) with pecans and put that on the bottom of my pie crust before pouring the pumpkin mix in! It smelled great and tasted awesome too...

The pumpkin mixture required cooking which was awesome.  And I added cloves to the recipe only because i love the way they smell. 

Here is her recipe if you want to try it: http://www.realbakingwithrose.com/2005/11/great_pumpkin_pie_1.html

My pie came out great - I love pumpkin pie and the crust was awesome! Mike liked it too!!!



*The gingersnap is the thin layer at the bottom of the pie...
Good things in this week's efforts: I had those crust guards that stop the crust from burning.  Those work great! i am going to use them all the time....I also used a pan under my  pie plate when cooking which was a good pickup from last week! The crust was worth the time and effort.  One of the goals for this year is to log one year of my 20 in getting my crust perfect! I am going to try to make homemade crust as often as possible....

Suggestions for next time: I might bake the pie another 5 minutes or so. It was still a little wetter than I would have liked although the crevasse on the pie is an indication of overbaking??? Not sure.  I may have not have enough batter too...I tasted it! Better to be patient!  I do think, also, I should have baked it on the bottom of the oven.  The recipe recommends a baking stone, which I don't have.  But I might have to get one.  Lastly, those pie crust sheets that show you when you have rolled to the right size probably would make life easier than my silly tape measure! I didn't take a picture of that...such an engineer...

Not sure what I am going to make next week...My brother is coming so I might let him choose.  Otherwise, a cream pie, like banana cream or coconut cream sounds interesting. I have never made any of those. Any suggestions???

8 comments:

  1. Looks yummy! Love that you are blogging! As for suggestions are you focusing only on pies at first and then moving on is anything game? I'm dying for a good old chocolate cake. One that is moist (gross word) but not too dense. Oooh...also, biscotti. I would love to know how to make it!

    ReplyDelete
  2. WOW !!!!! Great job Alanna - I have an amazing recipe for carrot cake when you get there. I hope you are sharing everything with co-workers or else you are going to have to run a monthly marathon.. I see a cookbook of "my years adventure" on its way......

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nicole and Anne, thanks for writing!
    Anne - Carrot Cake is a great idea - i would love to try that!
    Nicole - Biscotti is on the list - Lanie makes it all the time and it is great. And Chocolate Cake too. Over the holidays, someone brought cake balls to my house that were out of this world. Cake inside a hard shell. Almost like a pop em so I might try those too.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You are a baking magician!!! I love your blog and I can't wait to try baking the cheesecake.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have always found fruit pies to be difficult to master. You need the right consistency of liquid so the fruit doesn't dry out. The Fanny Farmer cookbook is a great addition for any cookbook collection. I also enjoy making Bread Puddings, but you have to get used to using the water bath, if you haven't already! Most importantly keep having fun!!!

    Brie

    ReplyDelete
  6. hey alanna! check out cook's illustrated pie crust---they use vodka and water. they say vodka makes it less tough....

    ReplyDelete
  7. Bryana, I love the Fanny Farmer - Mine has lost its binding...Great suggestion on bread pudding. I will add it to the list of recipes for the 52 weeks!

    Sarah - thanks for reading - I will look that one up too! Should we try pumpkin donuts in November??

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great job - can't wait to follow this... I will live vicariously through you!

    ReplyDelete